Delhi High Court’s CLAT Result Revision Order Faces Appeal from NLU Consortium

Delhi High Court’s CLAT Result Revision Order Faces Appeal from NLU Consortium

New Delhi, December 24, 2024 – The Consortium of National Law Universities (NLU Consortium) has filed an appeal with the Delhi High Court challenging a ruling issued by a single-judge bench, which mandated the revision of the CLAT 2025 results. The court's decision followed the discovery of errors in the question paper and answer key, which had affected the exam results.

Details of the Petition and Court’s Ruling

On December 20, 2024, the Delhi High Court examined a petition filed by Aditya Singh, a 17-year-old CLAT candidate, who raised concerns regarding discrepancies in the exam questions. The court found that two specific questions in the exam contained errors, which had affected candidates' results. Recognizing the seriousness of these discrepancies, the court ordered a revision of the CLAT 2025 results to ensure that all affected candidates were awarded corrected marks for these two questions. This ruling was intended to maintain fairness and consistency for all candidates who appeared for the exam.

NLU Consortium’s Appeal

In response to the ruling, the NLU Consortium filed an appeal against the court’s decision. The Consortium argued that the single-judge bench had overstepped its jurisdiction by intervening in the academic evaluation process. According to the Consortium, the CLAT answer key had been thoroughly reviewed and finalized by subject matter experts before being released. They emphasized that academic decisions should remain within the purview of experts and that judicial intervention should not override these decisions.

The Consortium further stated that courts should not interfere in academic matters, particularly when it comes to competitive exams, and that such decisions should be left to the relevant academic bodies.

Legal Arguments and Stance

The appeal presented by the NLU Consortium stresses the importance of preserving the autonomy of academic institutions and upholding the integrity of academic assessments. They argue that the CLAT evaluation process was conducted according to established standards and that the court’s decision undermines the authority of expert committees involved in the assessment.

Next Steps in the Appeal Process

The Delhi High Court will now consider the arguments put forth by both parties before making a final decision. The outcome of this appeal could set an important legal precedent regarding how courts engage with academic evaluation processes, particularly in competitive exams like CLAT.

CLAT 2025: Delay in First Allotment List, Answer Key Review to Impact Results

New Delhi, December 24, 2024 – Alongside the ongoing legal proceedings regarding the CLAT 2025 results, there has been a delay in the release of the First Allotment List for CLAT 2025 Counselling. Originally scheduled for December 26, 2024, the list's release has been postponed due to a review of the CLAT 2025 Answer Key, following the discovery of errors in Set A of the undergraduate (UG) question paper.

As a result, both the CLAT 2025 results and the First Allotment List will be impacted by this review. The Consortium of National Law Universities (CNLU) has assured candidates that they will be informed of revised dates and the updated counselling schedule through official communication channels.

Discrepancies in the CLAT 2025 Answer Key

The discrepancies identified in the CLAT 2025 Answer Key primarily relate to Set A, which was used to evaluate candidates’ responses. Specifically, questions 14 and 100 raised concerns among candidates due to inconsistencies in the answers provided. In response, a group of affected candidates filed a petition with the Delhi High Court, challenging the accuracy of the answer key.

Upon reviewing the case, the court confirmed that there were errors in question 14, directing that full marks be awarded to candidates who had selected the correct answer (option "C"). Furthermore, question 100 was deemed invalid, prompting the need for revisions in the answer key.

Impact on CLAT Results and Counselling Schedule

As a result of these revisions, both the First Allotment List and CLAT 2025 results will be delayed until the revised answer key is reviewed and incorporated into the evaluation process. The CNLU has not yet confirmed the revised dates for the counselling process or the release of the allotment list.

Despite these delays, the CNLU has reassured candidates that efforts are being made to maintain fairness and transparency throughout the revised process. Candidates are advised to stay updated through the official CLAT website and other communication channels for further information.

Tentative Schedule for CLAT 2025 Counselling Dates

The ongoing legal proceedings surrounding the CLAT 2025 exam and the delay in the release of the First Allotment List have left many candidates anxious. While the review of the answer key and the appeal from the NLU Consortium may lead to further delays, candidates can be assured that every effort is being made to ensure fairness and transparency throughout the process. Stay tuned to the official CLAT website and communication channels for updates on the revised dates.